Red Wheelbarrow
⇄Comparisons

Everyone says "AI writes code."
Ask what happens next.

There are two kinds of tools wearing that sentence. Some conjure new apps in their own cloud. Some work inside the repos you already run. Red Wheelbarrow is the second kind — with one difference nobody else has: a PR can't exist until your gates have passed.

Bucket one

Idea-to-app builders

Cursor, Replit, Lovable, Bolt, v0. Brilliant at zero-to-demo — a human (or the tool's own cloud) owns everything after generation: review, testing, hosting, consequences.

Bucket two · the real competition

Agents in your existing repo

Jira Rovo Dev, GitHub Copilot's cloud agent, Devin. Same shape as us — ticket in, PR out. The difference is what's guaranteed to be true when the PR appears.

01The grid

Nine questions to ask any coding agent.

Scored from each vendor's own public documentation as of July 2026. Every column header links to the full, sourced breakout.

Red Wheelbarrow Rovo Dev Copilot Devin Cursor Replit Lovable Bolt v0
Works on your existing repos (brownfield) ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ± — ± ±
Delivery contract: a PR into your repo ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ± — — — ±
User-defined fail-closed gates — no green checks, no PR ✓ — — — — — — — —
Independent AI reviewer with a veto, before the PR exists ✓ ± ± ± ± — — — —
Recon & plan approval as a hard gate before code ✓ ± ± ± — — ± — —
Bounded cost per task — converge or stop ✓ — — ± — — — — —
Agent blast radius limited to a pull request ✓ ✓ ✓ ± — — — — —
Your stack, your toolchain — not theirs ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ± — — —
Sprint planning by chat + built-in ticket board ✓ ± ± — — ± — — —
✓  yes, by design ±  partial — advisory, optional, or recent/limited —  not offered

Assessments reflect each vendor's public documentation and reporting as of July 2026 — the nuance behind every mark (and the sources) lives on the breakout pages. Examples: Rovo Dev and Copilot open draft PRs before checks pass and their reviewers are advisory; Devin caps spend per session but meters failed attempts; Lovable's docs state repos can only be exported, never imported. If a vendor ships something that changes a mark, tell us — we'll update it.

03Different job

Idea-to-app builders — greenfield.

Great at conjuring something new, fast. None of them ship gated changes into the codebase your business already runs — that's the job we do.

The question that sorts the whole market:

"What must be true before a human sees the change?" Our answer: your gates passed, an independent reviewer approved, and the budget held. Everyone else's answer is shorter.